May 2019

High child well productivity in Wolfcamp A points to down-spacing potential

Upcoming events:

Shale webinar

May 23, 2019
10:00AM (CDT) / 5:00PM (CEST)

Annual Summits

We are pleased to announce the dates for our Annual Summits. The agenda for each location is still being finalized but save the date in your calendar now. 

Houston: September 11-12
London: September 24-25
Singapore: October 8-9

Article: Occidental bids for Anadarko

Article: Re-frac market soars past 550 horizontal wells in 2018


Shale Upstream Analytics: Monthly reports with insights into key trends and developments in the North American tight oil and shale gas plays, including an overview of M&A activity, productivity metrics, short- and medium-term projections on production, spending, and valuation.

ShaleWellCube: Database with daily updates of official well data for the US, Canada and Argentina, covering over ~1,500,000 wells and permitsIt contains a detailed analysis of well curves, pad drilling, re-frack trends and well economics. A powerful tool that gives an in-depth insight into North American shale and conventional well activities.

Shale IntelReport with unique insights into supply and demand of key service segments of the US shale industry. Provides an industry overview of drivers behind drilling and completions activity, detailed analysis and forecast of the global frac services market, the US frac sand market overview, analysis of the US oilfield water management market as well as an overview of the US stimulation chemicals market.


Newsletter Subscription: If you are not yet a subscriber to this email or you would like to receive one of our other industry newsletters, please fill out the Newsletter Subscription Form.

Activity in many parts of the Permian Basin has already entered into large-scale manufacturing mode, but some elements of optimal development strategy have yet to be understood. One such area in the Permian Basin is found in Midland County. The horizontal unconventional development in Midland County started largely from the Wolfcamp B interval in 2011 and 2012, where a combination of depth and thickness of the pay zone offered the highest expected profitability. Over time, the stacked potential of Wolfcamp A and the Lower Spraberry/Jo Mill intervals have also been delineated, and the contribution of Wolfcamp B to total activity thus declined, although the original interval maintained its leading place in terms of total well completions even in 2018.

Some operators tested the Middle Spraberry and commercial results were achieved, but the trade-off between well productivity and costs suggests a sustainable preference toward the lower intervals. It is likely that the Middle Spraberry will become a more significant contributor to county activity only when the potential of the core layers has been exhausted. Finally, several tests of the Wolfcamp D/Cline interval have been conducted. However, this interval too will likely remain less profitable for major leaseholders in the county – in this case due to the gassy nature of the production stream.

Figure 1: A bar chart showing the horizontal first oil count in Midland County by year in number of wells from 2012 to 2018. Source: Rystad Energy ShaleWellCube, May 2019

The activity in Midland County has largely reached its manufacturing state with two-mile laterals being the standard as of 2018 across all key zones. Interestingly, while proppant intensity across the Wolfcamp A and B zones followed a logical depth differential pattern during most years, the typical Lower Spraberry completion has been more intensive from 2016 to 2018. To a large extent, this is explained by the operator mix, as operators that generally prefer higher proppant loading account for a larger share of Lower Spraberry activity than they do among the Wolfcamp A and B intervals.

In fact, there is a big difference between the “county master” Pioneer Natural Resources and most of the other operators. Pioneer’s latest frac completion technique – Version 3.0+ – became dominant in 2018, and the company has been pumping an average of 2,500 pounds per foot recently (2,800 in the Lower Spraberry intervals in 2017 and 2018). A lot of other operators – including Hunt Oil, Endeavor, ExxonMobil and Diamondback – still follow substantially more conservative frac designs, with proppant intensity ranging from 1,500 to 1,700 pounds per foot across all zones.

Figure 2: A graph showing the Midland County, median perforated length by year and zone from 2014 to 2018. Source: Rystad Energy ShaleWellCube, May 2019

Figure 3: A graph showing the Midland County, median proppant intensity by year and zone.Source: Rystad Energy ShaleWellCube, May 201

Midland is a good example of a county where normalized well productivity nearly reached today’s level way back in 2015. Further improvements in productivity per well were driven primarily by increases in average lateral length. Yet we see that 2017 was the best vintage ever for the Lower Spraberry and Wolfcamp B intervals, but normalized productivity seemingly declined last year. Meanwhile, Wolfcamp A’s normalized productivity remained robust in 2018.

Figure 4: Midland County, average decline curves by vintage in barrels of oil equivalent per day per 9,000 feet, two-stream. Source: Rystad Energy ShaleWellCube, May 2019

Figure 5: A bar chart showing the Midland County, average six-month recovery by vintage in thousand boe per 9000 feet, two-stream. Source: Rystad Energy ShaleWellCube, May 2019

In our view, this is largely explained by differences in well spacing experiments in different zones. In 2017 and 2018, we generally observe clear degradation in normalized productivity for child wells across the Lower Spraberry and Wolfcamp B zones. In particular, child wells in the Lower Spraberry intervals exhibit degradation of more than 20% compared to parent wells. Meanwhile, parent and child wells within Wolfcamp A wells performed at the same level in 2017 and 2018. This implies that there is still some potential for down-spacing within the Wolfcamp A interval in Midland. From a spacing unit value perspective, the inflection point is normally reached after productivity per well starts declining.

 A bar chart showing the Midland County, average six-month recovery by well type in thousand boe per 9000 feet, two-stream. Source: Rystad Energy ShaleWellCube, May 2019