Insights
/
Thought Leadership
Two paths forward: Trump vs Harris and their impact on Latin American energy
The energy landscape in Latin America is undergoing a profound transformation, shaped by a complex interplay of geopolitical dynamics, economic trends, and environmental concerns. As nations navigate challenges such as fluctuating oil prices, resource management, and the push for renewable energy, key developments are reshaping the region's role in global energy markets. From Venezuela's declining oil production to Brazil's booming pre-salt discoveries, the energy sector is a focal point of opportunity and tension. The relationship between the United States and Latin America adds another layer of complexity, influencing trade, investment, and political cooperation. The contest between former President Donald Trump and current Vice President Kamala Harris provides two different visions of what this relationship will look like, even as it becomes clear that the future of energy in Latin America will be crucial for the region and global energy dynamics.
Read this special insight from W. Schreiner Parker, Managing Director for Latin America at Rystad Energy.
Latin America has seen significant developments in the energy sector in recent years, some positive and some not. Venezuela, once one of the world's largest oil producers, has faced a steep decline in production due to political instability, economic mismanagement, and U.S. sanctions. This has had significant implications for global oil markets. Brazil has made substantial discoveries in its offshore pre-salt oil fields, now being put into production, positioning itself as a major player in international oil markets. These reserves have attracted foreign investment and prompted Brazil to become a key oil exporter. In 2013, Mexico enacted significant energy reforms to attract foreign investment in its oil and gas sector, moving away from the state monopoly. However, recent political shifts have raised concerns about the potential rollback of these reforms. Argentina's Vaca Muerta formation is one of the largest shale reserves in the world. The country has been working to develop this resource, which could transform its energy landscape and reduce dependence on imports.
At the same time, many Latin American countries are investing heavily in renewable energy sources, like wind and solar, to diversify their energy portfolios and combat climate change. Countries like Chile and Costa Rica are leading in this transition. There has also been increased activism surrounding environmental protection, and indigenous rights have affected oil and gas exploration and extraction in various regions. Conflicts often arise over land use and environmental degradation in countries like Peru, Ecuador and Colombia. More broadly, relationships with global powers, especially the U.S. and China, influence energy dynamics. For instance, China's investments in oil and infrastructure in countries like Brazil and Venezuela have implications for energy geopolitics. Fluctuating oil prices and changing global investment trends have posed challenges for financing new projects. Countries are increasingly focusing on attracting private investment while balancing public interests. These trends reflect a complex interplay of economic, political, and environmental factors that will continue to shape the energy landscape in Latin America.
The relationship between the United States and Latin America is multifaceted, encompassing economic, political, social, and cultural dimensions. The U.S. has several trade agreements with Latin American countries, including the USMCA (formerly NAFTA) with Mexico and Canada. The U.S. is a major trading partner for many Latin American nations, exporting goods and services while importing commodities. American companies invest heavily in various sectors across Latin America, including energy, manufacturing, and technology. This investment supports economic development but can also lead to tensions regarding labor practices and environmental standards. The U.S. engages with Latin America through diplomatic channels, focusing on democracy promotion, human rights, and anti-corruption efforts. However, relations can be strained due to various countries' differing political ideologies and government policies.
The U.S. has been involved in responding to political crises in countries like Venezuela, Nicaragua, and Bolivia, often through sanctions, diplomatic pressure, or support for opposition movements. There is also strong collaboration with Latin American countries on issues like drug trafficking and organized crime, providing assistance and training to local law enforcement and military forces. Migration from Latin America to the U.S. remains a significant issue, with discussions around border security and humanitarian assistance. The U.S. has focused on addressing the root causes of migration, such as violence and economic instability. There are strong cultural ties, with millions of Latin American immigrants living in the U.S. This diaspora contributes to the social and cultural landscape of the U.S. and fosters connections between the regions. Climate change is a growing area of cooperation, with the U.S. and Latin American countries working together on conservation, renewable energy, and sustainable development initiatives.
China's increasing presence in Latin America through investments and trade poses a challenge to U.S. influence. The U.S. is working to strengthen relationships to counterbalance this growing influence. Perceptions of the U.S. in Latin America vary widely, influenced by historical interventions, current policies, and cultural exchanges. Soft power initiatives are crucial in improving relations and fostering goodwill. Overall, the relationship is dynamic, influenced by changing political landscapes, economic needs, and social factors in both regions. The U.S. continues to navigate challenges and opportunities to maintain strong ties with Latin America. Considering the above, a Trump or Harris presidency would likely lead to distinct approaches to energy policy in Latin America, each with its own implications.
A Trump administration would likely prioritize fossil fuel development, promoting U.S. energy independence and potentially allowing for increased investments in oil and gas projects across Latin America. This could strengthen ties with countries rich in oil reserves, like Brazil. The administration might advocate for fewer environmental regulations, encouraging exploration and production in regions with significant energy resources. Reversing the Biden administration's pause on new LNG liquefaction could spur economic growth but raise concerns over environmental impacts. Trump's focus on America First policies might lead to a reevaluation of trade agreements affecting energy imports and exports, potentially impacting energy prices and investments.
A Harris administration would likely emphasize clean energy and climate change initiatives, fostering partnerships with Latin American countries to develop renewable energy projects. This could include solar and wind energy investments, particularly in regions with abundant resources. Harris would likely prioritize international climate agreements, encouraging Latin American nations to adopt sustainable practices. This could lead to increased funding for the region's green energy projects and technologies. The Harris administration might focus on social equity in energy access, supporting initiatives providing renewable energy solutions to underserved communities in Latin America, and fostering economic and environmental justice.
The energy landscape in Latin America is at a pivotal juncture, influenced by a myriad of factors ranging from geopolitical tensions to environmental imperatives. As countries like Venezuela grapple with decline and Brazil and Argentina emerge as energy powerhouses, the region's role in global energy markets becomes increasingly complex. The contrasting visions of U.S. leadership under Trump and Harris further highlight the potential for divergent energy policies that could either bolster fossil fuel development or accelerate the transition to renewable resources. As Latin America continues to navigate these challenges and opportunities, its future energy strategies will impact regional economies and reverberate across global markets. The interplay of investment, political will, and social responsibility will ultimately determine how the region shapes its energy future—one that is critical for sustainable development and international collaboration in addressing climate change.